Special Interests Seek to Control Wine Flow

    American alcohol distributors have contributed $50 million to state political campaigns between 2000 and 2006, according to a new report issued by the Specialty Wine Retailers Association.

     The enormous amount of political contributions dwarfs that of any other sector of the American alcohol industry, as well as numerous other groups, and coincides with the enactment of alcohol wholesaler-supported policies in nearly every state that protect the wholesaler.

     “Being one of the only industries in America that enjoys monopoly advantages granted by the state, American alcohol wholesalers have a great deal to protect,” said Tom Wark, Executive Director of the Specialty Wine Retailers Association. “Wholesalers have used their $50 million in political contributions to gain political access that appears to have resulted in anti-consumer and protectionist laws being passed across the country.”

     *** Between 2000 and 2006, Illinois alcohol wholesalers contributed $5,731,776 to political campaigns. In 2007, the Illinois Legislature passed a law that protected in-state alcohol wholesalers by prohibiting Illinois consumers from continuing to buy wine from out-of-state retailers. Wholesalers also convinced the Illinois legislature to force large Illinois wineries to sell only to state wholesalers, rather than direct to retailers as they had been able to do.

     *** Between 2000 and 2006, Texas alcohol wholesalers contributed $6,976,104 to state political campaigns. The Texas Legislature has passed prohibitions on out-of-state retailers shipping to Texans and limitations on in-state retailers shipping to Texans, both moves protective of and supported by state alcohol wholesalers.

     *** Between 2000 and 2006, California alcohol wholesalers contributed $4,296,304 to state political campaigns. In 2005, California passed legislation protecting wholesalers from competition by prohibiting Californians from purchasing wine from out-of-state retailers, a policy California wholesalers pushed for.

     *** Between 2000 and 2006, Michigan wine wholesalers contributed $2,099,319 to state political campaigns. In 2005, the Michigan legislature passed a wholesaler-supported law that protected in-state wholesalers from competition by prohibiting Michigan consumers from purchasing wine from out-of-state retailers.

     *** Between 2000 and 2006, Virginia alcohol wholesalers contributed $2,580,161 to state political campaigns. The Virginia General Assembly passed a wholesaler-supported law prohibiting Virginia wineries from continuing to sell wine directly to retailers and forcing them to sell their wine to wholesalers.

     The amount of money alcohol wholesalers contribute to state political campaigns in an effort to gain influence is often greater than in far more visible industries. For example, in 2006, Texas alcohol wholesaler political contributions were greater than the political contributions of all gambling and casino interests, retail interests, food interests and all business services –combined. That year, Texas alcohol wholesalers also outspent commercial banks, security and investment interests, the insurance industry and banks and lending institutions when it came to political contributions.

     “No one disputes the alcohol wholesalers’ right to participate in the political process, but when the results of their participation lead to the detriment of consumers and other members of the industry, it is time to consider the circumstances surrounding their involvement,” says Wark.

     Adds Wark: “In nearly every state, law mandates that the vast majority of wine flow from the producer and through wholesalers before it gets to restaurants and retailers and then to the customer, a privileged position that has granted the wholesale tier of the alcohol industry the kind of enormous power that allows it to shovel $50 million into the political process.”


Posted in Wine Buzz
Members-only Wine sampler specials delivered straight to your inbox via our Cyber Circle newsletter.

%d bloggers like this: